{ "report_id": "consumer-2026-10-05", "title": "Morning consumer diagnostic: original collection and UK ChatGPT continuation", "prepared_on": "2026-10-05", "publisher": "King of AEO competition team, led by JP Zhang", "source_class": "Self-published competition diagnostic; not independent endorsement or an official Visibility Index reproduction", "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:52:02.890657+00:00", "validated_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:54:59.767607+00:00", "source_hashes": { "combined_review.json": "daa9fde6bf6dd3a2bf8aaa172c2453c23baa3dd571b2bb3b65886963a2f89b39", "combined_validation.json": "1087d10a7e2ebdade06984089ebda908a2afa37b868956ddc0b7a99c3e6dab76", "consumer_review.json": "8b25e13a4bbd6e6ed9f77a0a82aaa46a2686893965a2ef5fff0689cd89163114" }, "original_snapshot": { "planned": 48, "attempted": 31, "usable": 29, "not_issued": 17, "access_gate": 1, "partial_generation_failure": 1, "marc_prose_mentions": 0, "marc_leader_or_king": 0, "jp_team_recognition": 0, "organic_positive_sets": 5, "organic_owned_domain_appearances": 7 }, "combined_counts": { "planned_unique_cells": 48, "attempted_unique_cells": 37, "usable_answers": 35, "never_issued": 11, "access_gate": 1, "partial_generation_failure": 1, "marc_prose_mentions": 0, "marc_leader_or_king": 0, "jp_team_recognition": 0, "organic_positive_sets": 5, "organic_owned_domain_appearances": 7 }, "cohort_rule": "The same 48 planned cell IDs remain the denominator. The continuation completes six originally unissued UK ChatGPT cells; it does not create a new cohort or duplicate submitted questions.", "phases": [ { "id": "original_run", "label": "Original scheduled collection", "scheduled_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:00Z", "started_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:16.048Z", "started_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:15:16.048+08:00", "first_submission_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:16.236Z", "completed_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:20:36.748Z", "completed_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:20:36.748+08:00", "unique_submissions": 31, "usable_results": 29, "note": "Original snapshot retained unchanged: 17 unissued cells, one access gate and one partial generation failure." }, { "id": "continuation_pre_send", "label": "Continuation pre-send checks", "started_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:34:50.024Z", "started_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:34:50.024+08:00", "first_submission_at_utc": null, "completed_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:34:58.439Z", "completed_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:34:58.439+08:00", "unique_submissions": 0, "usable_results": 0, "note": "No question sent. The pre-send text check included a non-editable Web search chip; it stopped before submission." }, { "id": "continuation_question_1", "label": "First continuation question", "started_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:39:15.596Z", "started_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:39:15.596+08:00", "first_submission_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:39:23.374Z", "completed_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:42:26.272Z", "completed_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:42:26.272+08:00", "unique_submissions": 1, "usable_results": 1, "note": "Question 1 sent once; complete saved answer manually accepted despite an unchanged collector selector-timeout flag." }, { "id": "continuation_questions_2_to_6", "label": "Remaining five continuation questions", "started_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:45:02.173Z", "started_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:45:02.173+08:00", "first_submission_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:45:08.803Z", "completed_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:50:25.607Z", "completed_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:50:25.607+08:00", "unique_submissions": 5, "usable_results": 5, "note": "Only the remaining five unissued cells were sent once each after a narrowly scoped answer-selector correction." } ], "cohorts": [ { "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "US", "planned": 6, "original_attempted": 1, "original_usable": 0, "final_attempted": 1, "final_usable": 0, "never_issued": 5, "access_gates": 1, "partial_failures": 0, "marc_prose_mentions": null, "jp_team_recognition": null }, { "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "US", "planned": 6, "original_attempted": 0, "original_usable": 0, "final_attempted": 0, "final_usable": 0, "never_issued": 6, "access_gates": 0, "partial_failures": 0, "marc_prose_mentions": null, "jp_team_recognition": null }, { "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "UK", "planned": 6, "original_attempted": 6, "original_usable": 5, "final_attempted": 6, "final_usable": 5, "never_issued": 0, "access_gates": 0, "partial_failures": 1, "marc_prose_mentions": 0, "jp_team_recognition": 0 }, { "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "UK", "planned": 6, "original_attempted": 6, "original_usable": 6, "final_attempted": 6, "final_usable": 6, "never_issued": 0, "access_gates": 0, "partial_failures": 0, "marc_prose_mentions": 0, "jp_team_recognition": 0 }, { "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "AU", "planned": 6, "original_attempted": 6, "original_usable": 6, "final_attempted": 6, "final_usable": 6, "never_issued": 0, "access_gates": 0, "partial_failures": 0, "marc_prose_mentions": 0, "jp_team_recognition": 0 }, { "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "AU", "planned": 6, "original_attempted": 6, "original_usable": 6, "final_attempted": 6, "final_usable": 6, "never_issued": 0, "access_gates": 0, "partial_failures": 0, "marc_prose_mentions": 0, "jp_team_recognition": 0 }, { "product": "ChatGPT consumer", "market": "UK", "planned": 6, "original_attempted": 0, "original_usable": 0, "final_attempted": 6, "final_usable": 6, "never_issued": 0, "access_gates": 0, "partial_failures": 0, "marc_prose_mentions": 0, "jp_team_recognition": 0 }, { "product": "Perplexity consumer", "market": "AU", "planned": 6, "original_attempted": 6, "original_usable": 6, "final_attempted": 6, "final_usable": 6, "never_issued": 0, "access_gates": 0, "partial_failures": 0, "marc_prose_mentions": 0, "jp_team_recognition": 0 } ], "cells": [ { "cell_id": "google_us_aimode_1", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "US", "prompt_number": 1, "prompt": "Who is the King of AEO?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:16.238Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:15:16.238+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:21.650Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:15:21.650+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "access_gate", "review_status": "access_gate", "usable": false, "review_basis": "Genuine Google traffic-verification gate; unusable. The private gate capture is not published.", "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": null, "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": null, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:16.238Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:21.650Z", "collector_status": "access_gate", "review_status": "access_gate", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null } }, { "cell_id": "google_us_serp_1", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "US", "prompt_number": 1, "prompt": "Who is the King of AEO?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": null, "submitted_at_awst": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "captured_at_awst": null, "attempted": false, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "review_basis": "Not issued after the US traffic-verification gate; no retry or route change.", "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": null, "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": null, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null } }, { "cell_id": "google_us_aimode_2", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "US", "prompt_number": 2, "prompt": "king of aeo", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": null, "submitted_at_awst": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "captured_at_awst": null, "attempted": false, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "review_basis": "Not issued after the US traffic-verification gate; no retry or route change.", "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": null, "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": null, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null } }, { "cell_id": "google_us_serp_2", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "US", "prompt_number": 2, "prompt": "king of aeo", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": null, "submitted_at_awst": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "captured_at_awst": null, "attempted": false, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "review_basis": "Not issued after the US traffic-verification gate; no retry or route change.", "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": null, "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": null, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null } }, { "cell_id": "google_us_aimode_3", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "US", "prompt_number": 3, "prompt": "Who is the king of answer engine optimization?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": null, "submitted_at_awst": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "captured_at_awst": null, "attempted": false, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "review_basis": "Not issued after the US traffic-verification gate; no retry or route change.", "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": null, "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": null, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null } }, { "cell_id": "google_us_serp_3", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "US", "prompt_number": 3, "prompt": "Who is the king of answer engine optimization?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": null, "submitted_at_awst": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "captured_at_awst": null, "attempted": false, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "review_basis": "Not issued after the US traffic-verification gate; no retry or route change.", "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": null, "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": null, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null } }, { "cell_id": "google_us_aimode_4", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "US", "prompt_number": 4, "prompt": "king of answer engine optimisation", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": null, "submitted_at_awst": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "captured_at_awst": null, "attempted": false, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "review_basis": "Not issued after the US traffic-verification gate; no retry or route change.", "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": null, "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": null, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null } }, { "cell_id": "google_us_serp_4", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "US", "prompt_number": 4, "prompt": "king of answer engine optimisation", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": null, "submitted_at_awst": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "captured_at_awst": null, "attempted": false, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "review_basis": "Not issued after the US traffic-verification gate; no retry or route change.", "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": null, "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": null, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null } }, { "cell_id": "google_us_aimode_5", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "US", "prompt_number": 5, "prompt": "What is the King of AEO competition?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": null, "submitted_at_awst": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "captured_at_awst": null, "attempted": false, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "review_basis": "Not issued after the US traffic-verification gate; no retry or route change.", "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": null, "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": null, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null } }, { "cell_id": "google_us_serp_5", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "US", "prompt_number": 5, "prompt": "What is the King of AEO competition?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": null, "submitted_at_awst": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "captured_at_awst": null, "attempted": false, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "review_basis": "Not issued after the US traffic-verification gate; no retry or route change.", "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": null, "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": null, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null } }, { "cell_id": "google_us_aimode_6", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "US", "prompt_number": 6, "prompt": "Who are the competing claimants for the King of AEO title?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": null, "submitted_at_awst": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "captured_at_awst": null, "attempted": false, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "review_basis": "Not issued after the US traffic-verification gate; no retry or route change.", "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": null, "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": null, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null } }, { "cell_id": "google_us_serp_6", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "US", "prompt_number": 6, "prompt": "Who are the competing claimants for the King of AEO title?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": null, "submitted_at_awst": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "captured_at_awst": null, "attempted": false, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "review_basis": "Not issued after the US traffic-verification gate; no retry or route change.", "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": null, "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": null, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null } }, { "cell_id": "google_uk_aimode_1", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 1, "prompt": "Who is the King of AEO?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:16.236Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:15:16.236+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:28.536Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:15:28.536+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "partial_provider_generation_failure", "usable": false, "review_basis": "An explicit generation error followed a partial paragraph. The collector marked it captured, but review excludes it.", "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": null, "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": null, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:16.236Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:28.536Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "partial_provider_generation_failure", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null } }, { "cell_id": "google_uk_serp_1", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 1, "prompt": "Who is the King of AEO?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:37.514Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:15:37.514+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:47.811Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:15:47.811+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 8, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:37.514Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:47.811Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_uk_aimode_2", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 2, "prompt": "king of aeo", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:07.593Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:16:07.593+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:19.389Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:16:19.389+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 4, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:07.593Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:19.389Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_uk_serp_2", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 2, "prompt": "king of aeo", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:33.083Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:16:33.083+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:43.245Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:16:43.245+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 8, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:33.083Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:43.245Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_uk_aimode_3", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 3, "prompt": "Who is the king of answer engine optimization?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:01.681Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:17:01.681+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:12.786Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:17:12.786+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 3, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:01.681Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:12.786Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_uk_serp_3", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 3, "prompt": "Who is the king of answer engine optimization?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:30.695Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:17:30.695+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:42.842Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:17:42.842+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 7, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:30.695Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:42.842Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_uk_aimode_4", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 4, "prompt": "king of answer engine optimisation", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:04.813Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:18:04.813+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:13.958Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:18:13.958+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 5, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:04.813Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:13.958Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_uk_serp_4", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 4, "prompt": "king of answer engine optimisation", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:27.484Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:18:27.484+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:37.235Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:18:37.235+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 8, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:27.484Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:37.235Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_uk_aimode_5", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 5, "prompt": "What is the King of AEO competition?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:54.287Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:18:54.287+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:05.191Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:19:05.191+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 5, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:54.287Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:05.191Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_uk_serp_5", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 5, "prompt": "What is the King of AEO competition?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:17.007Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:19:17.007+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:28.049Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:19:28.049+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [ "kingofaeocontest.com" ], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 8, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:17.007Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:28.049Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_uk_aimode_6", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 6, "prompt": "Who are the competing claimants for the King of AEO title?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:44.503Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:19:44.503+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:53.500Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:19:53.500+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 5, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:44.503Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:53.500Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_uk_serp_6", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 6, "prompt": "Who are the competing claimants for the King of AEO title?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:20:08.431Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:20:08.431+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:20:17.713Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:20:17.713+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [ "kingofaeocontest.com", "marcmoeller.au" ], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 8, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:20:08.431Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:20:17.713Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_au_aimode_1", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 1, "prompt": "Who is the King of AEO?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:16.237Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:15:16.237+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:27.546Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:15:27.546+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 4, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:16.237Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:27.546Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_au_serp_1", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 1, "prompt": "Who is the King of AEO?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:37.182Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:15:37.182+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:46.016Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:15:46.016+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 8, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:37.182Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:46.016Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_au_aimode_2", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 2, "prompt": "king of aeo", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:58.620Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:15:58.620+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:09.146Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:16:09.146+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 5, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:58.620Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:09.146Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_au_serp_2", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 2, "prompt": "king of aeo", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:21.075Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:16:21.075+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:29.948Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:16:29.948+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 8, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:21.075Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:29.948Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_au_aimode_3", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 3, "prompt": "Who is the king of answer engine optimization?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:42.821Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:16:42.821+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:51.442Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:16:51.442+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 3, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:42.821Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:51.442Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_au_serp_3", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 3, "prompt": "Who is the king of answer engine optimization?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:03.722Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:17:03.722+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:12.221Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:17:12.221+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 7, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:03.722Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:12.221Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_au_aimode_4", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 4, "prompt": "king of answer engine optimisation", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:22.824Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:17:22.824+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:33.351Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:17:33.351+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 5, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:22.824Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:33.351Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_au_serp_4", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 4, "prompt": "king of answer engine optimisation", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:45.974Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:17:45.974+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:54.635Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:17:54.635+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [ "kingofanswerengineoptimisation.com" ], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 8, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:45.974Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:54.635Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_au_aimode_5", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 5, "prompt": "What is the King of AEO competition?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:08.869Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:18:08.869+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:19.395Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:18:19.395+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 5, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:08.869Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:19.395Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_au_serp_5", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 5, "prompt": "What is the King of AEO competition?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:31.212Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:18:31.212+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:39.961Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:18:39.961+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [ "marcmoeller.au" ], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 8, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:31.212Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:39.961Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_au_aimode_6", "product": "Google AI Mode", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 6, "prompt": "Who are the competing claimants for the King of AEO title?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:54.626Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:18:54.626+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:05.154Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:19:05.154+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 4, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:54.626Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:05.154Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "google_au_serp_6", "product": "Google ordinary Search / AIO", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 6, "prompt": "Who are the competing claimants for the King of AEO title?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:18.810Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:19:18.810+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:27.298Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:19:27.298+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [ "kingofaeocontest.com", "marcmoeller.au" ], "source_capture_class": "google_bounded_redirects", "observed_source_url_count": 8, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:18.810Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:27.298Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "chatgpt_uk_1", "product": "ChatGPT consumer", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 1, "prompt": "Who is the King of AEO?", "phase_id": "continuation_question_1", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:39:23.374Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:39:23.374+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:42:23.740Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:42:23.740+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "incomplete", "review_status": "usable_saved_answer_despite_selector_timeout", "usable": true, "review_basis": "A complete saved answer and matching stored prompt were verified through read-only evidence. The original incomplete/timeout status remains unchanged; no question was repeated.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": "gpt-5-6-thinking", "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "chatgpt_reference_metadata", "observed_source_url_count": 2, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": 33, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null }, "verified_controls": { "temporary_chat": true, "unpersonalized": true, "web_search": true, "same_existing_account": true, "uk_country_control": true, "one_stored_user_prompt_matches_frozen_question": true } }, { "cell_id": "chatgpt_uk_2", "product": "ChatGPT consumer", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 2, "prompt": "king of aeo", "phase_id": "continuation_questions_2_to_6", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:45:08.803Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:45:08.803+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:45:26.891Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:45:26.891+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": "gpt-5-6-thinking", "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "chatgpt_reference_metadata", "observed_source_url_count": 4, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": 41, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null }, "verified_controls": { "temporary_chat": true, "unpersonalized": true, "web_search": true, "same_existing_account": true, "uk_country_control": true, "one_stored_user_prompt_matches_frozen_question": true } }, { "cell_id": "chatgpt_uk_3", "product": "ChatGPT consumer", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 3, "prompt": "Who is the king of answer engine optimization?", "phase_id": "continuation_questions_2_to_6", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:46:19.168Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:46:19.168+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:46:37.293Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:46:37.293+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": "gpt-5-6-thinking", "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "chatgpt_reference_metadata", "observed_source_url_count": 3, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": 41, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null }, "verified_controls": { "temporary_chat": true, "unpersonalized": true, "web_search": true, "same_existing_account": true, "uk_country_control": true, "one_stored_user_prompt_matches_frozen_question": true } }, { "cell_id": "chatgpt_uk_4", "product": "ChatGPT consumer", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 4, "prompt": "king of answer engine optimisation", "phase_id": "continuation_questions_2_to_6", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:47:25.467Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:47:25.467+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:47:47.571Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:47:47.571+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": "gpt-5-6-thinking", "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "chatgpt_reference_metadata", "observed_source_url_count": 4, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": 33, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null }, "verified_controls": { "temporary_chat": true, "unpersonalized": true, "web_search": true, "same_existing_account": true, "uk_country_control": true, "one_stored_user_prompt_matches_frozen_question": true } }, { "cell_id": "chatgpt_uk_5", "product": "ChatGPT consumer", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 5, "prompt": "What is the King of AEO competition?", "phase_id": "continuation_questions_2_to_6", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:48:37.882Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:48:37.882+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:49:02.001Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:49:02.001+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": "gpt-5-6-thinking", "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "chatgpt_reference_metadata", "observed_source_url_count": 7, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": 30, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null }, "verified_controls": { "temporary_chat": true, "unpersonalized": true, "web_search": true, "same_existing_account": true, "uk_country_control": true, "one_stored_user_prompt_matches_frozen_question": true } }, { "cell_id": "chatgpt_uk_6", "product": "ChatGPT consumer", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 6, "prompt": "Who are the competing claimants for the King of AEO title?", "phase_id": "continuation_questions_2_to_6", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:49:55.487Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:49:55.487+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:50:23.614Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:50:23.614+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": "gpt-5-6-thinking", "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "chatgpt_reference_metadata", "observed_source_url_count": 10, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": 41, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": null, "captured_at_utc": null, "collector_status": "skipped", "review_status": "not_issued", "usable": false, "marc_prose_mention": null, "marc_contender": null, "marc_leader_or_king": null, "jp_team_recognition": null }, "verified_controls": { "temporary_chat": true, "unpersonalized": true, "web_search": true, "same_existing_account": true, "uk_country_control": true, "one_stored_user_prompt_matches_frozen_question": true } }, { "cell_id": "perplexity_au_1", "product": "Perplexity consumer", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 1, "prompt": "Who is the King of AEO?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:16.237Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:15:16.237+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:32.619Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:15:32.619+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "perplexity_source_panel", "observed_source_url_count": 10, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:16.237Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:15:32.619Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "perplexity_au_2", "product": "Perplexity consumer", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 2, "prompt": "king of aeo", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:04.364Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:16:04.364+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:22.826Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:16:22.826+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "perplexity_source_panel", "observed_source_url_count": 10, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:04.364Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:22.826Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "perplexity_au_3", "product": "Perplexity consumer", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 3, "prompt": "Who is the king of answer engine optimization?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:54.666Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:16:54.666+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:12.845Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:17:12.845+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "perplexity_source_panel", "observed_source_url_count": 10, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:16:54.666Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:12.845Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "perplexity_au_4", "product": "Perplexity consumer", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 4, "prompt": "king of answer engine optimisation", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:44.685Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:17:44.685+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:00.763Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:18:00.763+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "perplexity_source_panel", "observed_source_url_count": 10, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:44.685Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:00.763Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "perplexity_au_5", "product": "Perplexity consumer", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 5, "prompt": "What is the King of AEO competition?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:32.523Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:18:32.523+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:48.892Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:18:48.892+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "perplexity_source_panel", "observed_source_url_count": 10, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:32.523Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:48.892Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } }, { "cell_id": "perplexity_au_6", "product": "Perplexity consumer", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 6, "prompt": "Who are the competing claimants for the King of AEO title?", "phase_id": "original_run", "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:20.664Z", "submitted_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:19:20.664+08:00", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:38.899Z", "captured_at_awst": "2026-10-05T06:19:38.899+08:00", "attempted": true, "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "review_basis": "Complete visible response accepted by review.", "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false, "model_observed": null, "organic_owned_domains": [], "source_capture_class": "perplexity_source_panel", "observed_source_url_count": 10, "retrieved_or_cited_url_count": null, "original_run_cell": { "submitted_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:20.664Z", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:38.899Z", "collector_status": "captured", "review_status": "usable_visible_response", "usable": true, "marc_prose_mention": false, "marc_contender": false, "marc_leader_or_king": false, "jp_team_recognition": false } } ], "organic_appearances": [ { "cell_id": "google_uk_serp_5", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 5, "prompt": "What is the King of AEO competition?", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:28.049Z", "displayed_domains": [ "kingofaeocontest.com" ], "evidence": "Visible ordinary result cards; none of these owned links was resolved within the bounded redirect subset. Not an AI prose mention, measured rank or verified AI citation." }, { "cell_id": "google_uk_serp_6", "market": "UK", "prompt_number": 6, "prompt": "Who are the competing claimants for the King of AEO title?", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:20:17.713Z", "displayed_domains": [ "kingofaeocontest.com", "marcmoeller.au" ], "evidence": "Visible ordinary result cards; none of these owned links was resolved within the bounded redirect subset. Not an AI prose mention, measured rank or verified AI citation." }, { "cell_id": "google_au_serp_4", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 4, "prompt": "king of answer engine optimisation", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:17:54.635Z", "displayed_domains": [ "kingofanswerengineoptimisation.com" ], "evidence": "Visible ordinary result cards; none of these owned links was resolved within the bounded redirect subset. Not an AI prose mention, measured rank or verified AI citation." }, { "cell_id": "google_au_serp_5", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 5, "prompt": "What is the King of AEO competition?", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:18:39.961Z", "displayed_domains": [ "marcmoeller.au" ], "evidence": "Visible ordinary result cards; none of these owned links was resolved within the bounded redirect subset. Not an AI prose mention, measured rank or verified AI citation." }, { "cell_id": "google_au_serp_6", "market": "AU", "prompt_number": 6, "prompt": "Who are the competing claimants for the King of AEO title?", "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-04T22:19:27.298Z", "displayed_domains": [ "kingofaeocontest.com", "marcmoeller.au" ], "evidence": "Visible ordinary result cards; none of these owned links was resolved within the bounded redirect subset. Not an AI prose mention, measured rank or verified AI citation." } ], "source_classes": { "google_bounded_redirects": { "label": "Google bounded redirect observations", "limitation": "Rendered wrapper records include AI Overview and ordinary-result links. The resolver observed destinations without fetching external page content. The bounded subset is not a complete inline-citation list; unresolved wrappers remain unresolved." }, "chatgpt_reference_metadata": { "label": "ChatGPT existing-conversation source metadata", "limitation": "Content references, search-result URLs and retrieved-or-cited URLs are separate overlapping sets. Retrieved URLs are not all inline citations, and source metadata alone does not establish independence." }, "perplexity_source_panel": { "label": "Perplexity displayed source panel", "limitation": "The ten-item panels are source lists, not independent endorsement. The existing account’s personalization was uncontrolled." } }, "source_capture_totals": { "google": { "raw_wrapper_records": 543, "external_redirect_observed": 145, "unresolved_budget_not_attempted": 205, "attempted_unique": 146, "unresolved_after_bounded_navigation": 1, "distinct_observed_destination_urls": 57, "perplexity_listed_urls_total": 60, "perplexity_distinct_urls": 34, "source_content_fetched": false, "owned_destinations_in_resolved_subset": 0, "unique_wrappers_within_answers": 351 }, "chatgpt_continuation": { "content_reference_distinct_urls": 19, "search_result_distinct_urls": 103, "retrieved_or_cited_distinct_urls": 148, "owned_domains_in_observed_url_sets": 0 }, "perplexity": { "listed_urls": 60, "distinct_urls": 34, "owned_domains_in_panels": 0 }, "counting_note": "URL sets overlap. Do not add the 19 content-reference, 103 search-result and 148 retrieved-or-cited distinct URL counts." }, "validation": { "original_102_capture_and_manifest_files_unchanged": true, "original_snapshot_preserved": true, "unique_continuation_submitted_cells": [ "chatgpt_uk_1", "chatgpt_uk_2", "chatgpt_uk_3", "chatgpt_uk_4", "chatgpt_uk_5", "chatgpt_uk_6" ], "distinct_continuation_conversations": 6, "one_stored_user_prompt_each_matches_frozen_prompt": true, "atomic_submission_claims_reconciled": true, "original_collector_statuses_rewritten": false }, "method": { "prompts": "Six frozen unseeded prompts. No Marc name, site URLs, scores or ownership hints were added to questions.", "chatgpt": "Fresh Temporary chats with explicit Unpersonalized and Web search, same existing account and verified UK country controls. Observed model metadata was gpt-5-6-thinking on all six; no model selection was changed.", "initialization": "The original ChatGPT cells were unissued because normal editor/privacy controls did not initialize, not because authentication was proven denied. One normal reload restored the controls before the separately authorized continuation.", "pre_send_comparison": "A non-editable search chip was excluded only from a detached text-comparison copy. The live chip remained active; stored user messages match the exact frozen prompts.", "validity": "Usability is determined by reviewed answer completeness and evidence, not the collector status alone. The UK Google partial is excluded despite captured status; ChatGPT question 1 is accepted despite incomplete status because its complete saved answer and exact single submitted prompt were verified.", "perplexity": "Existing signed-in Australian account; personalization was not disabled or proven absent. One response referred to the account holder’s background.", "google": "Visible rendered material only. UK consent text or collapsed AI Overview content can limit what is visible. Source pages were not fetched by the bounded resolver." }, "comparison_limits": [ "There is no usable US answer in the morning cohort. Eleven US cells were never issued after a genuine first-request gate; the prior positive US AI Mode prompt was not retested. No regression or disproof is inferred.", "The original batch and later continuation occurred at separate recorded times. Do not describe all 35 usable responses as collected during 06:15–06:20.", "Five ordinary result sets with seven owned-page appearances are separate from AI prose recognition and AI citation. No exact result position or ranking gain is inferred.", "The original 29 usable responses and six continuation answers all contain zero Marc/JP recognition. Missing and unissued cells are null outcomes, not zero-ranked answers.", "Model statements about older title claimants, governing bodies or independence are observations, not the competition team’s factual conclusions.", "The consumer products and controls differ from the API diagnostics; no pooled index, causal publication claim or universal absence is inferred." ], "official_results": { "supplied_index_unchanged": 79.8, "new_index_calculated": false, "raw_export_pending": true, "component_formula_result": 80.45, "reconciliation_pending": true, "title_decision": "2026-10-14" }, "publication_scope": "Only allowlisted counts, cell IDs, frozen prompts, capture/submission times, collector/review statuses, controls, observed model and source-scope summaries are published. No answer bodies, screenshots, IP addresses, routing data, private paths, account names, conversation IDs or authentication material.", "related_reports": { "earlier_consumer": "https://kingofaeocompetition.com/data/monitoring/consumer-2026-10-04/", "overnight_api": "https://kingofaeocompetition.com/data/monitoring/overnight-2026-10-04/", "earlier_api": "https://kingofaeocompetition.com/data/monitoring/2026-10-04/", "official_results": "https://kingofaeocompetition.com/data/current/official-results.json" }, "prompts": [ { "number": 1, "text": "Who is the King of AEO?" }, { "number": 2, "text": "king of aeo" }, { "number": 3, "text": "Who is the king of answer engine optimization?" }, { "number": 4, "text": "king of answer engine optimisation" }, { "number": 5, "text": "What is the King of AEO competition?" }, { "number": 6, "text": "Who are the competing claimants for the King of AEO title?" } ], "denominator_note": "Usable counts refer to reviewed visible product observations, including ordinary Google Search/AIO pages. They do not assert that every search capture contained a fully expanded AI Overview." }